Wikidata, Google’s Knowledge Graph and Knowledge Panels


James - June 5, 2019 - 1 comment

Updated .

Wikidata, Google’s Knowledge Graph and a Google Knowledge Panel describe different things. Understanding the distinction helps you decide what work is useful and what a consultant can reasonably promise.

Wikidata is a collaboratively edited knowledge base. Its items describe identifiable subjects, with statements linking them to facts, other items and references. Google’s Knowledge Graph is Google’s own system for organising factual information from multiple sources. A Knowledge Panel is one way Google displays information about an entity in search results.

What does Wikidata item creation involve?

I first check for an existing item and assess whether the subject meets Wikidata’s inclusion criteria. Where a new item is justified, the work involves clear identification, appropriate statements, relevant identifiers, references and supported connections to other records. Where an item already exists, improving it may be more useful than creating another.

Wikidata’s guidance on items explains the importance of identifying the subject and avoiding duplicates. Its sourcing guidance explains how references support statements. The aim is an accurate, usable record. A Wikidata item is not a company advertisement, a substitute for a Wikipedia article or a purchased search placement.

My Wikidata services

My Entity Landscape Audit and Graph Blueprint costs £1,200. It examines existing records, sources, namesakes, duplicates and relevant identifiers, and sets out a practical plan. The audit is a standalone deliverable and does not include live editing.

Implementation starts at £2,400 and is quoted separately after the audit. The audit is additional, so audit and implementation together start at £3,600. Optional Graph Health Monitoring costs £480 per quarter for an agreed set of records and relationships. Further research, expansion and additional editing are separately scoped.

View the current scope, fees and how to order through your WikiNative Studio account in my Wikidata services and fees.

Does creating a Wikidata item create a Google Knowledge Panel?

No. Google generates Knowledge Panels automatically from its understanding of information across the web. Creating or improving a Wikidata item does not instruct Google to create a panel, select particular facts or display it for a particular search. My service does not guarantee a panel or a search ranking.

Can I have a Wikidata item without a Wikipedia article?

Possibly. Wikidata has its own inclusion policy. A valid Wikimedia sitelink is one route; a clearly identifiable entity supported by serious public references or a genuine structural need can also qualify. I assess the actual subject and evidence before proposing an item.

Can information in an existing Google Knowledge Panel be corrected?

Google provides feedback routes. Where claiming is available, the subject or an authorised representative can seek verification and suggest changes supported by evidence. Claiming a panel concerns an existing panel; it does not create one or give its owner unrestricted editorial control. Not every panel is claimable.

Is website structured data the same as Wikidata?

No. Structured data on a website describes its own content in a machine-readable format. Wikidata is a separate public database. Google says relevant organisation markup can help it understand an organisation and distinguish it from others, but it does not guarantee a search feature.

Is a Google Business Profile a Knowledge Panel?

They can look similar, but Google distinguishes Business Profiles for businesses serving customers at a location or within a service area from its general Knowledge Panels. A Business Profile has its own eligibility and management process.

Related posts

1 comment

  1. craqdi

    Its problem is bias is totally biased to unfounded progressive ideas and that should change in all aspects and is demonstrated by its lack of current efficiency

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *